Home » Blog » Case Studies

Category: Case Studies

Scaphoid Fractures

The Scaphoid is a small kidney bean shaped bone in the wrist that is vulnerable to injury, especially in high-energy situations as British Superbike rider Dan Linfoot discovered after a crash during round 6 of the championship at Brands Hatch. As the photos show he was lucky that the accident wasn’t more serious.




The Scaphoid although small has a number of extremely important functions within the wrist including preventing the wrist from buckling under pressure. It is also unique in that the bone is almost entirely covered with articular cartilage, this means that it is unable to heal in the same way that most broken bones would and so must be kept absolutely still so new bone formation can occur across the fracture site. This coupled with the fact that the Scaphoid has a very poor blood supply means that it can often take 10-12 weeks of immobilisation in a plaster to heal. If the bone fails to heal (a non-union) then due to the alteration in wrist biomechanics patients will often go on to develop a well recognised pattern of arthritis in the wrist know as a SNAC wrist (Scaphoid non-union advanced collapse). This is not something that happens immediately but over a period of years following the injury. This means that if cast immobilisation has been unsuccessful then an operation to add bone graft to the fracture site and stabilise it can be done to prevent a SNAC wrist in the future.


Treatment of an acute un-displaced fracture is either in a plaster to immobilise the wrist or the Scaphoid can be fixed using a special type of orthopaedic screw (a variable pitch headless compression screw). The screw is placed under x-ray guidance in the operating theatre through a very small incision of only 1-2 mm. The implant then compresses the fracture and provides the stability that the fracture needs to heal without the need for a plaster cast. This should in turn allow a faster return to normal activities, or in Dan’s case we are hoping to get him back on his bike for round 9 at Silverstone.

Finger joint replacement: A patients journey

Finger joint replacements can be a great way of alleviating the pain of arthritis whilst allowing you to retain or even improve the function of your hand. Below is a patients experience of the procedure and the recovery afterwards. If you would like to discuss anything you read here further or think that you may be a candidate for the procedure please contact me to arrange a consultation.

Over the last 5 years I have been increasingly troubled by arthritis in the wedding ring finger causing considerable joint swelling and pain. My two main hobbies are playing the violin, and golf, both of which were becoming impossible. Following consultation with my GP, I was referred to Edward Powell Smith at The Duchy, Harrogate. The consultation was extremely positive in respect of joint replacement and I was booked in for an operation in June 2016.

The op was carried out under local anaesthetic, whereby my arm was numbed. During the operation, which lasted less than an hour, I felt  no discomfort whatsoever.

Within a week, the stitching was beginning to settle and I was referred to Emma Leather at Physio Action in Harrogate. This was initially a painful experience but movement and exercise are imperative for recovery.

Within a month, finger movement had improved considerably and the swelling was reducing. The key is constant joint exercise.

Within 3 months I was back  to playing the violin and swinging a golf club (with care). Within 6 months I was carrying out almost entirely normal activities.


A remarkable recovery, when I had originally given up hope of ever playing the violin playing and golf again.

John Bywater

Congratulations to Harrogate’s St George’s Archery Club

A Huge congratulations to Harrogate’s St George’s Archery club who won the club team title at the National Clout Archery Championships 2 weeks ago. I would especially like to congratulate Carol Fairbrother who has come back from a serious injury to her wrist to reclaim her title as the British Lady Barebow Champion of the seventh time. Not only is this a fantastic achievement but the competition also took place in the middle of storm Brian making the conditions particularly tough.

I would like to wish you every success for next year.